How to Keep Captive Killer Whales Happy

Ought to killer whales Skype? A brand new examine means that digital hyperlinks between captive orca populations is perhaps a technique to enhance the lives of those marine mammals.

The preserving of orcas, or killer whales, in captivity has been a matter of public controversy, particularly for the reason that launch of the documentary "Blackfish" in 2013. The movie facilities on the 2010 killing of a SeaWorld coach, Daybreak Brancheau, by a captive killer whale that had been captured from the wild in 1983.

On account of the general public outrage following the documentary, SeaWorld introduced in March 2016 that it could shut down killer-whale reveals in its parks, in addition to its orca breeding program. However orcas stay for many years (and a few have been identified to stay previous 100), and there are dozens in captivity that may stay at SeaWorld (and different captive-breeding institutions) for the remainder of their lives.

Now, two researchers on the College of Glasgow in Scotland have some options for tips on how to enhance these orcas' lives.

The options go means past providing orcas extra toys and actions. One concept is to determine audio communication channels between totally different captive populations — and even wild populations — to allow them to "discuss" to one another. One other is to determine feeding techniques that require whales to work collectively to get meals, as they do within the wild.

"We're at a stage the place, for essentially the most half, the bodily welfare of animals in captivity is nice and infrequently an excellent deal higher than within the wild," mentioned animal welfare knowledgeable Graham Legislation, one of many authors of a paper itemizing the options within the journal Worldwide Zoo Yearbook. "Nevertheless, the psychological welfare is an space that wants extra work." [Orca Gallery: See Gorgeous Photos of Killer Whales]

Orca psychology

Whales' psychological well being is on the heart of the controversy over Brancheau's loss of life. A male orca named Tilikum dragged Brancheau into the water after a present. As Outdoors journal reported, Tilikum's early years have been traumatic. He was captured and brought from his pod at age 2. (Within the wild, male whales usually stick with their moms for the remainder of their lives, and a son's survival depends upon his mom effectively into maturity.) The younger whale then was stored in a barren concrete pool in Iceland for a yr earlier than being transferred to a now-defunct marine park in British Columbia. There, Tilikum was bullied by two dominant females. In 1991, the three understimulated whales killed a part-time coach who slipped into their pool, Outdoors reported.

Tilikum was then offered to SeaWorld, the place, Outdoors reported, he had higher care however was nonetheless harried by dominant females. In 1999, Tilikum was concerned within the loss of life of a person who snuck in after hours to swim within the orca pool. (It is not identified whether or not Tilikum killed the person straight, although he did mutilate the person's physique.)

"Tilikum is mainly psychotic," Ken Balcomb, government director of the Heart for Whale Analysis, advised Outdoors journal. "He has been maintained in a state of affairs the place I believe he's psychologically unrecoverable when it comes to being a wild whale."

Although there are numerous arguments over whether or not killer whales needs to be stored in captivity, the very fact is that they're already there, Legislation advised Reside Science. As of 2016, there have been 56 captive orcas all over the world, based on the journal Worldwide Zoo Information. In some unspecified time in the future, Legislation mentioned, there could also be exhausting choices to make about whether or not captivity may save the species. [Marine Marvels: Spectacular Photos of Sea Creatures]

"The resident inhabitants of killer whales round Scotland are usually not doing very effectively, and shortly they could be extinct" as a result of excessive ranges of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) of their surroundings, Legislation mentioned. "We have no idea what species we may have to guard in captivity sooner or later," he added. "We ought to, nonetheless, the place doable, concentrate on the most effective strategies to take action."

A greater life

Legislation and his colleague Andrew Kitchener, principal curator of vertebrates on the Nationwide Museums Scotland, targeted on social, feeding, health and environmental suggestions for the care of killer whales. These suggestions haven't been examined, they cautioned, however all are primarily based on mimicking the whales' actions and surroundings within the wild.

Socially, the researchers instructed, killer whales may profit from communication with far-flung brethren. Orcas are vocally advanced and might even be taught new "dialects." Satellite tv for pc uplinks between marine parks might join disparate teams, Legislation and Kitchener wrote. Unusual as it would sound, zoos have used sounds to advertise pure conduct earlier than, Legislation mentioned. In 1989, researchers reported in Worldwide Zoo Yearbook that they'd used recorded gibbon calls to immediate a pair of gibbons in a London zoo to make their very own territorial cries and to mate. The sound of what gave the impression to be close by gibbons appeared to induce the primates to guard their territory and reproduce.

Animals apart from orcas additionally may profit from extra enriched soundscapes, Legislation mentioned. For instance, lions talk throughout prides with loud roars, and leopard calls appear to be filled with details about the caller's id, he mentioned.

"We must always assume extra about how unnatural it's to maintain zoo animals in acoustic isolation," Legislation mentioned.

The researchers additionally beneficial totally different strategies of feeding that will require orcas to take an energetic function to find meals. Movement-sensor feeders may very well be programmed to launch treats after whales carry out a activity. Strategies that require whales to work collectively might mimic the necessities of looking as a pod within the wild. Orcas are identified to be intelligent hunters: They make waves to clean seals off ice, they listen in on prey they usually even set traps.

Coaching might have interaction these sharp killer-whale brains, and construct stamina. Legislation and Kitchener instructed coaching whales to carry their breath for lengthy intervals, thus simulating the deep dives the whales do within the wild. Additionally they instructed extra naturalistic options in tanks, like kelp (actual or synthetic), synthetic boulders and wave-making machines. Acoustic supplies may very well be diverse in tanks to present whales one thing to echolocate off of, the researchers wrote. Tapes of ocean sounds may very well be performed to stimulate whales' senses.

All of those concepts, Legislation mentioned, should be examined scientifically. The general public debate over killer whales in captivity is very polarized, he mentioned, however trainers at SeaWorld and different marine parks are very smitten by bettering the welfare of their animals.

"So far as I'm conscious, husbandry adjustments have been already within the pipeline by quite a few organizations that maintain orca to create higher situations for them," Legislation mentioned. "I hope that the general public will assist any constructive makes an attempt to make issues extra attention-grabbing and difficult for animals in captivity."

Unique article on Reside Science.