A global manhunt for the terrorist behind the Berlin Christmas market bloodbath is underway amid claims police have 'no concept who they're searching for'.
Detectives are reportedly combing by CCTV footage seeking a lead after they launched their solely suspect from custody final evening, saying there was not sufficient proof to tie him to the atrocity.
Naved B, a Pakistani asylum seeker, had been detained within the fast aftermath of Monday's carnage following a tip-off from witnesses. However the 23-year-old, who had no blood on his garments and no accidents, denied having something to do with massacre, which claimed 12 lives and injured 48. Police wasted hours interrogating him.
A senior police officer instructed die Welt newspaper: 'We've got the fallacious man. The true perpetrator remains to be armed, at giant and may trigger additional injury.'
Inside hours of the discharge of Naved B's launch, Islamic State issued its first declare of accountability for the lorry assault on festive customers and revellers and hailed the motive force accountable a 'soldier'.
In a press release, the group's AMAQ information company stated: 'The executor of the operation in Berlin is a soldier of the Islamic State and he executed the operation in response to calls to focus on nationals of the coalition nations.'
In the meantime the killer behind the assault stays on the run and armed with a gun. Prosecutor Holger Münch warned of a 'severe risk' of one other 'important' terror assault and Berliners had been urged to remain indoors.
Will the lorry killer strike once more? Police and the safety companies are looking the terrorist behind the Christmas market assault
First image: Naved B, a Pakistani asylum seeker, had been detained within the fast aftermath of the carnage following a tip-off from witnesses (pictured with a blanket over his head). Nevertheless he was launched final evening attributable to an absence of proof
Terror assault chain of occasions: The polish lorry was hijacked when it arrived in Berlin and hours later was pushed by Christmas market crowds. The principle suspect was pursued on foot and arrested - but it surely seems he's the fallacious man. Police additionally raided the hangar he lives in with different asylum seekers on the Tempelhof airport
Carnage: The lorry used to kill a dozen individuals in Berlin on Monday evening was towed away from the scene on Tuesday
Brutal: White powder used to absorb blood left by the useless - one witness described a 'rivers of blood' operating by the market
Solemn: Angela Merkel closed her eyes as she attended a service on the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church on Tuesday evening
Grief: Two girls view the carnage on the Christmas market scene and sob as police warn a brand new assault could possibly be imminent
Vigil: A sea of candles and flowers cowl the pavement near the place the phobia assault occurred on Monday evening
United: The historic Brandenburg Gate in Berlin was illuminated within the colors of the German flag in tribute to the useless
Police have discovered the spot the place they assume the lorry was hijacked, believed to be subsequent to a department of the Thyssenkrupp firm in Berlin - round two miles from the market. Pictured, officers on the website on Tuesday
Horror 2016: These are all the phobia assaults carried out on German soil up to now yr, claiming the lives of 22 individuals
In response to Michael Behrendt, crime reporter for Die Welt, Berlin detectives had been completely at a loss over the assaults. 'The police don't know who they're searching for,' he stated.
'They haven't any weapon, no DNA traces.' He stated officers had been finding out CCTV footage however that 'till they've any concrete data, it's nonetheless fully unclear what they're coping with'.
The killer hijacked a juggernaut laden with metal to hold out the assault. The lorry's laptop system recorded a collection of stop-start manoeuvres 'as if somebody was studying drive'.
At 7pm native time it drove across the Christmas market on Breitscheidplatz Sq. a number of occasions, as if to construct up pace, earlier than switching off its headlights and charging at 40mph right into a crowd.
Victims together with youngsters had been despatched flying like bowling pins and crushed below the 25-ton HGV's wheels. The driving force jumped from the cab and raced from the massacre.
Solely six victims have been recognized however Italian Fabrizia Lorenzo, 31, transport specialist employee is lacking and her cell phone and journey go had been discovered within the crash zone.
After one other terror assault on German soil this yr it was revealed:
- Twelve persons are useless and 48 are injured - 16 significantly - after a lorry is pushed at 40mph by crowds on the well-known Breitscheidplatz Sq. Christmas market at 7pm on Monday evening.
- Hours earlier the lorry was hijacked from a Polish driver taking metal to Berlin from Italy. Lukasz City, a father of 1, was discovered shot useless in its cab. It's not but clear when he died.
- The attacker was adopted by a witness for a mile and a half – updating police on his cell phone – however who's then stated to have misplaced him within the metropolis's Tiergarten park. Police arrested Naved B based mostly on a witness description however later launched their sole suspect due to an absence of proof.
- Police commando squad raid a hangar at Berlin's Tempelhof airport, which was closed and used as a camp for refugees together with Naved B, who's believed to have entered Germany a yr in the past below a false identify. 4 males are questioned and a laptop computer and cell phone seized
- Angela Merkel lays white roses on the scene of the bloodbath and says 'we've to imagine we're coping with a terrorist assault'. Amid fears an asylum seeker is the perpertrator she says: 'It might be notably onerous to bear for all of us if it was confirmed that an individual dedicated this crime who requested for defense and asylum in Germany'
- The White Home says President Barack Obama has spoken by cellphone with Chancellor Merkel. Vladimir Putin has additionally supplied his condolences
Remembrance: Lit by candlelight, Mrs Merkel indicators a e-book of condolences on the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church final evening
Emotional: The Mayor of Berlin, Michael Müller, centre, bows his head as he attends the service alongside German politicians
Chancellor Angela Merkel and President Joachim Gauck led politicians on the service on the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church
German chancellor Angela Merkel, left and Berlin's mayor Michael Mueller, share a quiet phrase on the service in Berlin
Residents gathered on the Brandenburg Gate final evening, which was lit within the colors of the German flag in tribute to the useless
A lady fashioned a cross with candles on the pavement close to to the place the lorry ploughed into the Christmas market, killing 12
The location of the phobia assault within the centre of Berlin was tonight reworked right into a shrine to those that misplaced their lives
Simply 24 hours after the assault, Berliners stay defiant and benefit from the festivities at one other Christmas market within the metropolis
Candles are lit contained in the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church in Berlin, as town involves time period with the lack of final evening
Residents of Zurich, Switzerland, present their solidarity with the residents of Berlin by lighting candles at a Christmas market
EYEWITNESSES REVEAL THEIR TERROR FACING DEATH
Slender escape: Vacationer John Thompson and his daughter Annabelle, 11, on the market on Monday evening
A British household caught up within the terror assault have instructed how they narrowly escaped being hit by the truck.
John Thompson and his 11-year-old daughter had posed for an image on the Christmas market simply minutes earlier than it was devastated by the hijacked lorry.
Final evening the 59-year-old businessman revealed how he, his spouse Nicola, 48, and their daughter Annabelle had been amongst scores of Britons who witnessed the mass homicide – and needed to run for his or her lives.
The household, from Lepton in Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, had been on a three-day break within the German capital once they determined to go to the market.
Mr Thompson stated they survived solely as a result of they stopped for one thing to eat.
'We had been very, very shut,' he stated. 'We had been considering having meals elsewhere and had been strolling in the direction of that finish of the market when Nicola noticed a BBQ stall … and we determined to cease for some meals.
'Rapidly there was this almighty commotion and this truck was hurtling in the direction of us. I noticed the entrance finish of it. We didn't hold round and simply ran for our lives.
'My daughter thought it was fireworks however everybody else was operating away from the scene and we simply adopted them to the church steps on the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church … Annabelle was essentially the most shaken up by it. She thought it was fireworks. However right now is one other day and we've to hold on.'
His spouse added: 'You by no means assume one thing like this could occur to you, you possibly can't consider it, but it surely did. I simply stated to John, "let's cease and have some meals" … then there was this lorry rumbling by all of the stalls. There was a number of shouting and folks operating. It was very horrifying. It's horrible what has occurred to these poor individuals.'
One other British vacationer, Sara Dobler, recalled how she held a person's hand as he lay on the ground with extreme head accidents. She described the scene as 'like one thing from a horror movie'.
The 26-year-old, from South Wales, stated she didn't know what occurred to the person, however stated the expertise had 'traumatised' her.
Traumatised: Sara Dobler and her associate Rhys Meredith stated they had been 'traumatised' by what they'd witnessed on the market
'He was on the ground … he was mendacity there, he was attempting to rise up however his head harm was fairly extreme. So I simply held his hand and instructed him every part was going to be OK,' she instructed BBC Radio 5 Stay.
'Clearly there have been individuals mendacity on the ground. We weren't certain if it was purple wine or blood.'
Her boyfriend Rhys Meredith, 27, from Cardiff, had simply purchased meals on the Breitscheidplatz market along with her when the lorry smashed into the stalls, lacking the couple by about 10ft. 'There was clearly no try to try to decelerate – we've seen stalls obliterated into nothing,' Mr Meredith stated.
He described the 'completely horrific' scene as he tried to push stalls off individuals who had been trapped beneath. 'It's simply wonderful how a peaceable, festive, completely happy environment simply modified immediately and also you've simply received this scene of utter devastation,' he instructed BBC Information.
US pupil Luke Theis noticed 'two rivers of blood' following the assault. He and his girlfriend Lara Colombo, 22, had been on their solution to the market once they heard sirens and noticed individuals operating frantically away.
Bloodbath: Australian vacationer Trisha O'Neill, pictured, instructed of seeing 'blood and our bodies in every single place' after he mounted a curb and intentionally drove into crowds of individuals
'It was carnage in every single place,' he stated. 'There was blood everywhere in the flooring … No person was actually serving to anyone. Individuals had been operating. It was like each man for themselves. It was dusty and chaotic … two rivers of blood happening the ground.'
Mr Theis, from Washington, added: 'It's unsettling to assume that you're so near dying. One minute you're alive and having fun with the Christmas market after which you're useless and your loved ones has to spend Christmas with out you.'
One other witness, Jan Hollitzer, 36, stated he heard screams because the truck crashed by, however that the market was silent within the aftermath.
Mr Hollitzer, deputy editor of native information outlet Berliner Morgenpost, stated: 'First, I heard a noise, then he destroyed the cubicles available on the market and we heard some screams, after which the truck got here out of the market on the left facet.' He stated he noticed destroyed stalls, damaged glass and tables, and injured individuals mendacity on the bottom, including: 'There have been some individuals below the truck and it was actually scary, actually terrifying.'
Australian pupil Trisha O'Neill stated she noticed 'blood and our bodies in every single place'. 'Rapidly there was a giant growth and the individuals in entrance of me jumped on high of me,' she instructed ABC.
'I simply noticed this big black truck rushing by the markets crushing so many individuals after which all of the lights went out and every part was destroyed. I may hear screaming and all of us froze. Then all of a sudden individuals began to maneuver and elevate all of the wreckage off individuals, attempting to assist whoever was there.'
Miss O'Neill, who was celebrating her last lessons in Germany earlier than heading house, stated she noticed a number of individuals, from youngsters to the aged, mendacity on the ground immobile.
Mike Fox, from Birmingham, and his associate had been only a 'few metres' from the lorry because it smashed its manner by the market. 'My girlfriend noticed a toddler below the truck,' he stated. 'I noticed about 15 or 20 individuals injured, some had been shifting and a few weren't. Others had blood on them. I noticed one man being dragged away with blood on his face.'
Vivian Hilse, 15, a college pupil from Berlin, was on the market along with her buddy. She stated: 'We tried to run away however my finest buddy fell over and broke his leg … I used to be actually afraid. We received within the ambulance.
'It was solely after we had been within the hospital that we knew what had occurred. It's terrible, you don't really feel secure in your individual metropolis.'
Lana Sefovac, a Bosnian who lives in Berlin, was on the entrance of the market on the time of the assault.
Slaughter: American vacationer Luke Theis, pictured along with his girlfriend Lara Colombo, noticed 'two rivers of blood happening the ground' after the attacker mounted a curb and intentionally drove into crowds of individuals
She instructed N1 Tv in Bosnia: 'We had been at a stall as a result of we needed to purchase some meals. We had been fortunate we had been hungry as a result of if we had been on the promenade we'd have been victims.
'I used to be standing in entrance of the stall, my father was in entrance of me, my mum was behind. I heard a really, very noisy sound and after I turned in the direction of it, the very first thing I noticed was wooden flying throughout as a result of he actually smashed the primary picket sales space by driving very quick.
'He was driving instantly towards us, instantly into us, however then he made a flip as a result of he didn't wish to drive into (our) sales space however the place individuals had been. He needed to run individuals over.'
Belgian girl Carima Douch, who was working on the Zaventem airport in Brussels when the suicide bombings occurred in March, instructed of yet one more fortunate escape.
She instructed Dutch every day De Telegraaf every day after witnessing the Berlin assault: 'It is very tough. You're feeling completely powerless. And I'm speechless. The whole lot comes again once more. It's unbelievable that it's occurring another time.'
Her buddy, Carima Akel-Freie, a private assistant from Leuven, stated: 'We thought it will be enjoyable to go to the Christmas market. We had been going to remain there, however a bunch needed to depart to go and get a drink.
'I am actually completely happy that we determined to go together with them. It most likely saved our lives. 5 minutes later the assault occurred.'
Dutch photographer Roos Koman was visiting the market along with her boyfriend Stefan, having made the journey specifically to Berlin to see it. Simply half an hour earlier than the truck hit, they had been having fun with the Christmas market and had gone again to their resort simply 50 metres away.
One other British vacationer Emma Rushton remembered the lorry ploughing right into a Christmas market in Berlin at '40mph'.
Ms Rushton, from Rugby, Warwickshire, was out within the metropolis for the primary time when the car sped by the gang.
The Scout Affiliation employee noticed the truck tearing by the market, bringing down lights and crashing into customers, earlier than coming to a halt exterior Kaiser Wilhelm memorial church.
She instructed Sky Information : 'We had been about eight toes away from the place it occurred and we noticed all of it occur and I am actually grateful that we had not left the Christmas market two minutes earlier.
'I am operating on adrenaline in the meanwhile so every part is popping out fairly quick.
The entrance of the lorry which crashed by the Berlin Christmas market on Monday evening
'We arrived on the market round lunch time right now. We had by no means been to Berlin earlier than and it was our first vacation there.
'We determined to wander all the way down to the Christmas market and partake in a number of the mulled win that was being served in addition to searching for some gives.
'We had been sat and had been ingesting and by chance I broke my leg a number of years in the past, which suggests I've to sit down down for lots longer than most individuals would usually need to.
'When certainly one of my mates stated, 'let's go', I replied with 'give me two minutes' and that was after we heard a really loud bang and noticed the Christmas lights to our left being pulled down.'
ISIS supporters used an encrypted messaging service to name for extra assaults simply half an hour after the Berlin Christmas market atrocity, it has emerged.
A German-speaking fanatic reportedly urged members of the phobia group to hold out a repeat of the mass killing utilizing ways 'the enemy can by no means cease'.
German newspaper Bild reported that an ISIS follower had used Telegram to inform fellow extremists: 'You want nothing greater than a automobile... after which a correct intention and a Kuffar crowd.'
The lorry's authentic Polish driver, Lukasz City, a father of 1, was transporting metal beams into Germany, however was discovered shot within the cab after the crash. The gun has not been discovered.
The fear assault could possibly be a political catastrophe for Angela Merkel, who will search a historic fourth time period as German Chancellor subsequent yr. The German chief, who left white roses because the scene this afternoon, has staked a lot of her political capital in opening up Germany's doorways to refugees and in doing so divided a reunited land.
Within the aftermath of the atrocity, the attacker was adopted by a witness for a mile and a half – updating police on his cell phone – however who's then stated to have misplaced him within the metropolis's Tiergarten park.
On the premise of the outline of the attacker given to police by the witness, officers pounced on Naved B close to the park's victory column.
Police celebrated the swift arrest, with spokesman Winfrid Wenzel hailing the 'civic braveness' of the witness.
Overhead: This can be a clear view of the trail the lorry took by the now-destroyed Christmas market in central Berlin
Tragedy: Contained in the cab was the Polish driver who the lorry was hijacked from - he might have been murdered earlier than the crash
Horrific: The smashed entrance of the lorry used to kill individuals having fun with the run-up to Christmas. A wreath from one of many stalls was longed in its destroyed windscreen
Shut up: The shattered glass on the windshield of a truck on Tuesday after it ploughed by the Christmas market
Path of destruction: That is the trail taken by the killer truck driver - and reveals the way it mounted a slim strip of pavement round 80metres in size with the purpose of killing as many individuals as attainable. The white powder is believed to point out the place the our bodies fell
German Chancellor Angela Merkel (left) lays white roses on the blood-stained scene in Berlin on Tuesday
Sufferer: A physique dragged below the lorry's wheels lies coated with a gold blanket this morning on the rear of the stolen lorry
Aftermath: New images have emerged from the scene displaying how the highway across the lorry was strewn with our bodies, together with a physique by the cab
Grief: A whole lot of Berliners have visited the scene of the horror crash to depart tributes to those that misplaced their lives
Tributes: Flowers, candles and messages are being left on the scene of the atrocity right now as German involves phrases with the phobia assault
Prayers: A lady prays subsequent to a cross of lit candles on the Christmas market in Berlin near the message 'the sunshine is stronger than the darkness'
ANGELA MERKEL 'SHOCKED, SHAKEN AND SADDENED'
German chancellor Angela Merkel has stated she was 'shocked and really saddened' by the Berlin Christmas market assault which left 12 useless and nearly 50 injured, describing it as a 'horrible' deed.
Talking at a press convention Mrs Merkel stated the federal government 'assumed' it had been a terror assault, including that: 'We are going to discover the energy to proceed dwelling life as we wish to stay it in Germany - in freedom, openness and collectively.'
She stated: 'It's a horrible deed which one can not perceive. It took their lives; many individuals are injured, are combating for his or her lives and combating for his or her well being, and in these hours I in the beginning consider these individuals - the useless, the injured, their households, their mates, their kinfolk.
'I would really like you to know that we - all of us, the entire of the nation - are with you in deep disappointment.'
Mrs Merkel stated: 'We do not have something for sure, however we should assume it was a terrorist assault.
'It might be very tough for us to be taught human being dedicated this deed who got here to Germany to ask for refuge and asylum.
'It might be horrible for the entire Germans who're very lively daily in serving to asylum seekers and refugees. It might be repugnant for these which are serving to people who have come to this nation and are asking for our assist.'
She added: 'Tens of millions of individuals, together with myself, are asking ourselves, how are you going to stay with the truth that, whereas celebrating the festive season the place we wish to rejoice life, any person has come alongside and brought so many lives. I solely know that we don't wish to, and we can not stay with it.
'We don't wish to enable ourselves to be paralysed by terror. It is perhaps tough in these hours, however we'll discover a energy to proceed dwelling life as we wish to stay it in Germany, in freedom and openness and collectively.'
However aid later turned to helplessness because the authorities admitted they'd been losing their time with the Pakistani, whose DNA was not within the cab.
He arrived in Germany final New 12 months's Eve by way of the Balkans. He was dwelling in a hangar on the previous Tempelhof airport in the midst of Berlin, which police commandos raided at 4am yesterday seeking clues and accomplices.
Returning Jihadist fighters to Germany have instructed intelligence operatives that Isis regards the nation as a main goal for terror and has been striving all this yr for a 'spectacular' outrage to match these carried out in France.
Islamic State militants had even printed a terror handbook final month containing directions on utilizing a lorry to inflict most carnage.
Their chilling Rumiyah journal stated utilizing a car was probably the most profitable methods of 'harvesting' giant numbers of non-believers.
At 11am Chancellor Merkel spoke in regards to the carnage, saying: 'A complete nation is united with the victims and their survivors in deep mourning. All of us hope and many people pray for them.
'That they'll discover consolation and help. That they'll survive after this horrible assault.
'I do know that it ís notably onerous to bear for all of us, that an individual has dedicated this act who0 has requested for defense and asylum in Germany.
'Tens of millions of individuals have been asking: How can we stay with it that at a Christmas market - a spot of pleasure – a killer brings loss of life to so many individuals? I've no easy reply to this query.
'This Act might be punished as severely as our legal guidelines enable. We've got to imagine, in response to the newest information, that this was a terrorist assault.'
She would later go to the scene of the bloodbath with different ministers to put flowers and examine the carnage.
Armed police in Britain have been patrolling markets in main cities and surrounding them with a hoop of metal crash limitations to stop a car getting used as a weapon.
Police had thanked a member of the general public for serving to to seize Naved B, 23, because of an eagle-eyed witnesses who adopted him.
'Maybe he needed to hunt shelter in the dead of night', stated police spokesman Winfrid Wenzel, including that the police had been saved knowledgeable of his actions by the person tailing him from a 'secure distance.'
In the course of the pursuit he stayed on the road completely to emergency companies, updating them each few seconds the place the killer was heading.
He was captured close to the Victory Column - near town's zoo - by officers in a passing patrol automobile.
Police spokesman Wenzel added: 'With the assistance of this witness it was attainable to seize the suspect. 'This sort of civic braveness provides us braveness too .'
It seems, nevertheless, that the police had been hasty and the citizen tracked the fallacious man.
The Polish lorry driver whose truck was used within the Christmas market bloodbath was shot with a small-calibre pistol, in response to the inside minister of the state of Brandenburg Karl-Heinz Schröter.
As German police, the White Home and Germany's high safety official indicated the incident was seemingly terror associated, there was a chilling echo of the lethal terror assault within the French metropolis of Good in July.
The harrowing incident additionally comes amid repeated warnings from varied safety businesses that ISIS deliberate to wreak havoc on European nations throughout the festive season, particularly threatening Christmas markets.
Lukasz City (pictured), a 37-year-old father-of-one, was killed within the carnage that noticed a 25-tonne truck profession by Berlin's Breitscheidplatz Sq., which killed 12 and injured dozens extra
The boss, Ariel Zielinski, who can also be the motive force's cousin, stated they final spoke at noon however the man's spouse had been unable to succeed in him at 4pm - hours earlier than the incident. Mr Zielinski is pictured above with spouse Judyta Zurawska
Fabrizia Lorenzo, pictured, 30, is a transport specialist working in Berlin however her cousin stated they'd not heard from her since final evening
The normally merry streets turned scenes of chaos, with individuals being pulled from below the flattened picket stalls and others ferried off in ambulances, some tragically below white sheets.
The Die Welt newspaper stated that German intelligence had been warning metropolis authorities for the previous week of a attainable assault on a Christmas market.
Germany's justice minister says federal prosecutors, who deal with terrorism instances, had taken over the investigation.
Police used Twitter to induce locals to remain of their properties, to 'test suspicious objects' and inspired individuals to make use of a Fb security test family members had been secure.
German Chancellor Angela Merkel says she is 'mourning the useless', whereas The White Home stated: 'The USA condemns within the strongest phrases what seems to have been a terrorist assault on a Christmas Market in Berlin, Germany, which has killed and wounded dozens.'
The Polish proprietor of the lorry confirmed his driver was lacking.
Talking on Polish information channel TVN24, the proprietor of the haulage agency Ariel Zurawski stated his relative wouldn't have dedicated an act of terror: 'I can say hand on coronary heart that the person who drove into these individuals within the centre of Berlin was not my driver.
'That is my cousin. I've recognized him since I used to be born. I can vouch for him.
'My situation is that they did one thing to the motive force – they hijacked this car as a result of it was virtually within the centre of Berlin they usually had a superb car with which they may do what they did'.
Groups had been engaged on the lorry all morning earlier than it was taken away to a safe unit to be combed over for clues
Murderous: The fear suspect is believed to have shot useless the Polish driver of the truck earlier than utilizing it as a weapon hours later
Distressing: The world across the lorry was strewn with wreaths, garlands and even baubles torn from market stalls
Investigation: The lorry was given a police escort right now because it was taken away for forensic examination
Injury: The truck was adopted by its container, which housed metal being taken into Germany by a Polish driver
Chilly-blooded: The fear assault has shocked the world - and these photographs present how the emergency companies fought to save lots of the injured
Horror: MailOnline has muzzed the physique of 1 sufferer - the person was left mendacity below one of many wheels within the terror assault
Demise toll: The 80metre stretch of Berlin pavement was stained with blood left when the lorry driver steered into the crowds
Proof: The lorries tracker system says that it was began and stopped repeatedly after the hijacking, suggesting the motive force was studying transfer it
Demise toll: There are 12 useless - however 14 are critically or significantly injured in intensive care models throughout the nation
Alarm bells began ringing for the Polish haulage firm when the lorry's GPS confirmed the car was being pushed like a 'newbie'.
The readings seem to counsel the lorry was hijacked between 3pm and 4pm, in response to Luke Wasik, from the transport agency.
At three.19pm and three.44pm failed makes an attempt to begin the engine had been recorded.
The lorry was then pushed briefly distances in the direction of the Christmas market earlier than 5pm after which once more, simply after 5.30pm.
Throughout these quick journeys the GPS confirmed that the engine seemed to be 'choking' - so the corporate tried to contact the motive force to search out out what was occurring. Nevertheless, no-one answered the calls.
Mr Wasik instructed Polish web site WP Cash: 'It seems to be as if somebody was attempting to learn to drive this. He had issues with its operation.'
The lorry was pushed in the direction of the sq. at 7.34pm.The ultimate GPS studying was at 8pm, when the car turned off its headlights and ploughed by the market, forcefully.
Zurawski stated City arrived with a supply of metal at a department of the Thyssenkrupp firm in Berlin on Monday at 7 am. however was instructed to attend along with his supply till eight am the next day.
BERLIN TERROR ATTACK: A 23-year-old asylum seeker from Pakistan who arrived in Germany months in the past is in custody right now after utilizing a hijacked lorry to plough by this Berlin Christmas market killing 12 and injuring 48 others
The car left a path of devastation in its wake, in a chilling echo of the lethal terror assault within the French metropolis of Good in July - and comes only one hour after the Russian ambassador was shot useless in Ankara
The loss of life toll, which has risen from 9, was confirmed by Berlin Police on Twitter. The drive stated 48 individuals who had been injured - a few of them significantly - have been taken to hospital
Not less than 12 individuals have been killed and round 48 injured after a lorry ploughed by a crowd of customers at a busy Christmas market in Berlin
There have been harrowing scenes on Monday night in Berlin, after a number of individuals misplaced their lives simply days earlier than Christmas
The car mounted the pavement earlier than tearing by stalls and customers available in the market on Breitscheidplatz Sq., exterior the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church within the German capital's most important procuring space
A British man and his associate had been 'only a few metres' from being hit by the lorry. He described the horrific scenes afterwards, during which the couple noticed a toddler mendacity below the truck.
He instructed Ruptly TV: 'The truck simply got here in. It didn't seem like stopping. It simply missed us by a number of metres. I seemed to Sam to see if she was okay after which nearly instantly the truck had gone previous us. We tried to see who was injured.
'There have been two individuals who gave the impression to be okay - one was bleeding a bit. I helped some individuals elevate the facet of one of many stalls in order that any person could possibly be dragged from beneath and clear a number of the wooden out of the best way.
'There have been youngsters available in the market. I did not see, however my girlfriend noticed a toddler below the truck afterwards. I noticed about 15 or 20 individuals injured - some had been shifting and a few weren't shifting. Others had unhealthy blood on them.'
British vacationer Mike Fox, from Birmingham, stated the massive truck missed him by about three meters because it drove into the market, tearing by tables and picket stands. 'It was positively deliberate,' he stated.
Mr Fox stated he helped individuals who appeared to have damaged limbs, and stated others had been trapped below Christmas stands, including: 'We had been available in the market, exterior the cathedral and we had simply had mulled wine then as we had been leaving the massive truck got here by.
'It went simply previous me, previous my girlfriend. I feel it missed me by three metres, missed her by 5. It got here in by the doorway, hit the edges of the limitations after which carried on previous us.
'You do what you possibly can to assist who you possibly can, actually. It occurred so quick that there was nothing we may do to cease it - if we might tried to cease it we'd have been crushed.'
Emma Rushton from Rugby in Warwickshire, noticed the lorry rush previous her at pace and stated it couldn't have been an accident.
She instructed Sky Information she solely missed being caught within the chaos as a result of she had climbed up some steps to sit, including: 'The stall that we purchased our mulled wine from was fully crushed. Individuals had been tearing off picket panels to get out.
'It was not an accident. It was going 40mph, it was in the midst of the market. There was no manner that it may have come off the highway and it confirmed no indicators of slowing down.'
'I heard a giant noise after which I moved on the Christmas market and noticed a lot chaos...many injured individuals,' Jan Hollitzer, deputy editor in chief of Berliner Morgenpost, instructed CNN. 'It was actually traumatic.'
Richard Clarkson, from Brighton, instructed the Irish Unbiased he was on the close by Irish Bar with mates when the incident occurred.
As information of the incident unfold globally, White Home Nationwide Safety Council spokesman Ned Worth stated america condemned it as an obvious terror assault
Bystanders stated the crash 'couldn't have been an accident' because the articulated lorry sped previous them and into the gang
Police detectives climbed over the particles to go looking the truck, as investigators labored by the evening to ascertain what had occurred
A lot of British vacationers had been amongst those that witnessed the appalling crash - which occurred regardless of authorities being warned of a attainable assault
The Die Welt newspaper stated that German intelligence had been warning metropolis authorities for the previous week of a attainable assault on a Christmas market
Police in Berlin saved members of the general public up to date, tweeting the truck might have been stolen and was carrying metal beams - making it much more lethal because it careered by the gang
World leaders have united within the aftermath of the tragedy, with Boris Johnson and Francois Hollande sending their condolences to
Brighton resident Mr Clarkson stated: 'I simply walked out and I noticed the truck, the windscreen was damaged, I did not see any our bodies they had been very fast to cowl them up I feel.
MERKEL FACES BACKLASH OVER 'OPEN-DOORS' POLICY
Angela Merkel has confronted a livid backlash over her open-doors coverage on immigration after a refugee launched a lethal lorry assault on a Christmas market within the coronary heart of Berlin.
The suspected radical Islamic attacker - a bogus asylum seeker who got here to the nation in February below a false identify - murdered 12 and injured dozens gathered on the market final evening.
German chancellor Merkel has come below big political stress for permitting almost one million individuals fleeing battle and poverty within the Center East and Africa to reach within the nation this yr and final.
And final evening she confronted anger from the far-right anti-immigration Different for Germany (AfD) get together with outstanding member Marcus Pretzell tweeting: 'When will the German state of legislation strike again? When will this cursed hypocrisy lastly cease? These are Merkel's useless! (hash)Good (hash)Berlin.'
The document inflow of migrants within the final 12 months has hit Merkel's recognition rankings and boosted help for the AfD with the 62-year-old having just lately introduced her intention to face for re-election once more subsequent yr.
The German chief has staked a lot of her political capital in opening up Germany's doorways to refugees and in doing so divided a reunited land.
Final evening Merkel reacted shortly to the atrocity, with spokesman Steffen Seibert tweeting: 'We mourn the useless and hope that the many individuals injured might be helped.'
'The phrase terrorist is being thrown round rather a lot in the meanwhile and folks appear scared.'
Katarzyna Goebel - initially from Poland however who now lives in Berlin - was ingesting wine on the market when the hijacked truck ploughed into the gang.
She stated: 'I used to be only a few metres away, ingesting wine after I heard a noise and that is after I noticed the truck driving into the market.
'Some individuals screamed however lots of people had been saying it was a coincidence and we should always keep calm.
'I used to be at that actual stall only a few minutes earlier than the truck appeared. It was essentially the most terrifying second of my life'.
One eye witness stated the lorry had no lights on when it smashed into the market.
He stated: 'He simply drove onto the sq. from the Kant road. That needed to have been intentional, as a result of his lights weren't switched on. After which I simply heard this loud bang and hysterical screaming.'
Australian Trisha O'Neill instructed the Australian Broadcasting Company she was solely metres from the place the truck smashed into the crowded market.
'I simply noticed this big black truck rushing by the markets crushing so many individuals after which all of the lights went out and every part was destroyed.
'I may hear screaming after which all of us froze. Then all of a sudden individuals began to maneuver and elevate all of the wreckage off individuals, attempting to assist whoever was there.'
O'Neill stated there was 'blood and our bodies in every single place'.
In a press release launched after the crash, President elect Donald Trump stated: 'Our hearts and prayers are with the family members of the victims of the horrifying terror assault in Berlin.
'Harmless civilians had been murdered within the streets as they ready to rejoice the Christmas vacation.
'ISIS and different Islamist terrorists regularly slaughter Christians of their communities and locations of worship as a part of their world jihad.
'These terrorists and their regional and worldwide networks should be eradicated from the face of the earth, a mission we'll perform with all freedom-loving companions.
Sabrina Glinz, an American vacationer, was locked in her resort after various buildings within the space had been positioned on lockdown.
Watching the scene unfold from the 15th flooring, she instructed Sky Information: 'You simply hold seeing individuals getting loaded into ambulances and it does not appear to finish. Simply the white sheets overlaying them.'
She added: 'The road that he has to have gone in you could have do a u-turn on the road to show round and as a substitute of doing a u-turn he turned proper instantly into the market.
'There was completely no manner he may have unintentionally, he went straight into it then veered to the left and is now again onto the principle road had been the truck is resting.
'He went again to the start had been it was busiest after which simply careered by the buildings'.
An eyewitness stated: 'I simply noticed this big black truck rushing by the markets crushing so many individuals after which all of the lights went out and every part was destroyed'
The 25-tonne car left a path of devastation because it tore by the normally merry festive market
One eye witness stated the lorry had no lights on when it smashed into the market, including He stated: 'He simply drove onto the sq.. That needed to have been intentional, as a result of his lights weren't switched on'
Carnage: There was absolute carnage in Berlin because the festive market became a harrowing and tragic scene
Federal prosecutors, who deal with terrorism instances, have taken over the investigation in response to justice minister Heiko Maas, who stated in a tweet 'we're mourning with the kinfolk' of the victims
The car mounted the pavement earlier than rushing by a crowd of customers, tearing by stalls because it travelled the size of the market
Aerial photographs from the scene present the devastating aftermath on the crash scene and particles across the truck
Germany's justice minister says that federal prosecutors, who deal with terrorism instances, had been taking up the investigation
German intelligence had apparently been warning metropolis authorities for the previous week of a attainable assault on a Christmas market
There are dozens of ambulances and hearth engines on the scene as they work to get better our bodies and assist these injured
The truck travelled for some 80 toes by the market - crashing by market stalls and harmless bystanders
Ambulances line the streets as rescue employees deal with these on the scene and attempt to save these critically injured
Russian President Vladimir Putin has despatched condolences to Germany after a truck ploughed right into a Christmas market in Berlin, killing 12 individuals and injuring 48, calling the assault 'stunning'.
'This crime in opposition to peaceable civilians is stunning in its savage cynicism,' Putin wrote to German Chancellor Angela Merkel and President Joachim Gauck, in response to a press release on the Kremlin's web site.
Overseas Secretary Boris Johnson tweeted his condolences following the 'horrible tragedy', whereas the Overseas Workplace warned Britons travelling to Germany of a excessive danger from terrorism.
In recommendation up to date after the crash, it stated: 'There could also be elevated safety in place over the Christmas and New 12 months interval, together with at Christmas markets and different main occasions which may appeal to giant crowds.
'It is best to stay vigilant and comply with the recommendation of native authorities.'
It's understood the market is a daily festive deal with for customers and contains stands that supply seasonal meals resembling bratwurst, candy waffles, candied fruits in addition to mulled wine and selfmade eggnog.
Fb has activated a security test function for travellers and locals on the social community.
A police cordon remained on the website on Tuesday morning, although elements of the Christmas market had been re-opened.
Commuters walked quietly previous the picket stalls and Christmas bushes available in the market, lots of which had been nonetheless lit up with white lights. White screens had been erected round a big a part of the realm the place the articulated lorry got here to a cease.
As emergency companies ready to take away the lorry, tributes began appearing close by. Individuals laid purple candles and flowers, whereas others wept as they handed the scene.
A glass jar with a white candle inside had a word pinned to it, which learn: 'I'm Berlin for extra humanity and sympathy.'
Italian Overseas Minister Angelino Alfano stated he was 'deeply stricken and pained' by what he reffered to as an assault in Berlin.
In a press release offered by Italy's overseas ministry, Alfano expressed closeness to Germans 'on this unhappy second that as a substitute needs to be of pleasure and peace within the strategy to the Christmas holidays.'
Alfano stated assaults 'will not change our willpower to fight terrorism' alongside worldwide companions and specifically Germany, saying the 2 nations are in strict coordination.
An injured man is pushed to an ambulance on the website of an accident as scores of others are handled on the scene
The car sped by a crowd of customers on the Christmas market on Breitscheidplatz Sq. close to the Kurfuerstendamm Avenue in west Berlin
Police subsequently stated 12 individuals had been killed and one particular person has been detained over the incident - which comes lower than every week earlier than Christmas
Ambulances and police rushed to the realm after the motive force drove up the pavement of the market in a central sq. in style with vacationers, in scenes harking back to the lethal truck assault within the French metropolis of Good in July
The heavy items car might be seen clearly broken - and the motive force was later apprehended on the metropolis zoo
Police stand exterior a tent close to the Christmas market in Berlin as these injured within the devastating crash are handled
Armed police are standing guard on the entrance to the market and round Berlin as safety is tightened
A number of individuals have died whereas dozens have been injured as police examine the alleged assault at a market exterior the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church
Police, hearth crews and paramedics raced to the scene of the incident in Berlin as a rescue effort received underway
The truck bumped into the market exterior the landmark Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church round 7pm on Monday night
Police had stated the primary indications from the investigation recommended the truck crash was a terror assault
The horrific incident has taken place at a website in style amongst vacationers - with many Brits on the scene
Germany has not in recent times suffered a large-scale assault from Islamist militants like these seen in neighbouring Belgium and France.
Nevertheless it was shaken by two smaller assaults in Bavaria over the summer time, one on a practice close to Wuerzburg and one other at a music pageant in Ansbach that wounded 20 individuals.
Each had been claimed by Islamic State.
And authorities officers have stated the nation, which accepted almost 900,00zero migrants final yr, many from the war-torn Center East, lies within the 'crosshairs of terrorism.'
In mid-October, police arrested a Syrian refugee suspected of planning a bomb assault on an airport in Berlin.
The 22-year-old man dedicated suicide in jail shortly after his arrest.
Solely final week it was revealed 12-year-old boy tried to bomb the Christmas market within the city of Ludwigshafen with a nail bomb - twice.
The boy, of Iraqi-German dad and mom, was radicalised solely just lately and is now within the care of the native youth authorities.
PICTURE EXCLUSIVE: Polish lorry driver who fought for his life as fanatic shot him useless then hijacked truck in Berlin bloodbath was returning to his spouse to organize Christmas presents, his distraught household reveals
The Polish lorry driver whose truck was used within the Christmas market bloodbath was stabbed and shot useless, it was revealed right now.
Lukasz City, a 37-year-old father-of-one, was killed within the carnage that noticed a 25-tonne truck profession by Berlin's Breitscheidplatz Sq., which killed 12 and injured dozens extra.
This afternoon it emerged that he was returning to his spouse to organize Christmas presents when the assault unfolded.
The proprietor of Polish haulage agency, Ariel Zurawski, stated the motive force - additionally his cousin - was hijacked and killed by the person suspected of finishing up the assault.
An image reveals married Mr City smiling within the cab of a lorry, in 2008, confirmed by his boss and cousin, whereas one other picture emerged, taken from CCTV, shortly earlier than he was hijacked.
Alarm bells began ringing for the Polish haulage firm when the lorry's GPS confirmed the car was being pushed like a 'newbie'.
Proprietor of Polish haulage agency, Ariel Zurawski (left), insisted the motive force Lukasz City (proper) - additionally his cousin - was hijacked
Lukasz City leaves behind a spouse, Zuzanna and a 17-year-old son. The 37-year-old driver disappeared after parking his lorry at a depot in Friedrich-Krauze-Ufer and going for a kebab.
Mr Zurawski, stated: 'Once I spoke to him he was saying it was an odd space of Berlin as a result of it was stuffed with Muslims.
'The one Germans he got here into contact with had been these on the depot.'
He added that Mr City's spouse, Zuzanna, was now in Germany.
He stated: 'Lukasz's spouse didn't wish to establish the physique, she is simply too upset. A member of the family recognized Lukasz as a substitute.
'She could be very distressed, as is their son, they usually have had no help from both Germany or Poland. No psychologists, specialists, she is on her personal.
'Lukasz's plan was to be house by Thursday and put together presents for Christmas.
'Police in Gryfinie confirmed me the horrible picture of Lukasz. His face was all bruised and had been minimize with a knife. You possibly can inform he put up a battle.
'However I don't consider that one man may have killed my cousin. He was a robust six-foot-two and weighed 130kg. It needed to do a bunch of individuals.'
For his horrified household, Mr City's loss of life comes as a double tragedy after it was revealed that his brother Konrad had taken his personal life simply three years earlier.
Speaking to MailOnline exterior his home within the village of Sobiemysl close to Gryfino in northwest Poland, Mr Zurawski stated: 'This can be a double tragedy for the household. Two years in the past his brother killed himself.
'Now their father has been taken into hospital affected by shock.
Mr Zurawski had earlier confirmed the drivers loss of life saying: 'Sadly the motive force is useless. His physique was discovered within the cabin. His final contact was at 3pm when his spouse referred to as him.
'Nevertheless, she could not discuss as a result of she was at work. She stated she would name at 4pm however she was unable to contact him.
'I've not acquired official affirmation however I needed to recognise him and I needed to say that he was my driver.
'Stab wounds had been clearly seen on the picture which depicted solely my cousin's face. It was actually clear that he was combating for his life. His face was swollen and bloodied.
'Police knowledgeable me that he suffered a gunshot wound. Regardless of being stabbed he was shot useless.'
Inside minister Karl-Heinz Schröter confirmed the loss of life as he ready for a phone name with the opposite inside ministers of the 16 states that make up the German republic.
The Scania-made lorry is owned by firm Arial Zurawski, which is predicated in Gryfino in northwest Poland (pictured from the corporate web site)
The lorry was travelling from Italy to Berlin to drop off its load, earlier than returning to Poland.
It had reached the German capital when the hijacking occurred.
He stated that after reaching his vacation spot in Friedrich-Krauze-Ufe, Mr City had parked and gone to get a kebab sandwich, planning to unload his cargo of 24 tonnes of metal elements the subsequent morning.
Round midday, the 2 cousins spoke. Mr City stated he was hungry and that there have been few Germans within the neighbourhood the place he parked, largely Muslims.
The car's GPS recording confirmed it didn't journey removed from when it was hijacked to the second it crashed.
The readings seem to counsel the lorry was hijacked between 3pm and 4pm, in response to Luke Wasik, from the transport agency.
At three.19pm and three.44pm failed makes an attempt to begin the engine had been recorded.
The lorry was then pushed briefly distances in the direction of the Christmas market earlier than 5pm after which once more, simply after 5.30pm.
Throughout these quick journeys the GPS confirmed that the engine seemed to be 'choking' - so the corporate tried to contact the motive force to search out out what was occurring. Nevertheless, no-one answered the calls.
Mr Wasik instructed Polish web site WP Cash: 'It seems to be as if somebody was attempting to learn to drive this. He had issues with its operation.'
The lorry was pushed in the direction of the sq. at 7.34pm. The ultimate GPS studying was at 8pm, when the car turned off its headlights and ploughed by the market, forcefully.
Mr Zurawski described the bizarre actions on the truck's GPS that point out Mr City was not in management.
He stated: 'The automobile was began up, turned off, pushed ahead, then backward. As if any person inside was studying drive.'
Poland's prime minister, Beata Szydlo, stated that the Pole was 'the primary sufferer of this heinous act of violence.'
When answerable for the hijacker, the car mounted the pavement earlier than rushing by a crowd of customers on Breitscheidplatz Sq., exterior the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church, a busy procuring space in west Berlin.
The normally merry streets turned scenes of chaos, with individuals being pulled kind below the flattened picket stalls and others ferried off in ambulances, some tragically below white sheets.
Italian girl is feared lacking in Berlin Christmas market bloodbath after her cellphone and metro go had been discovered at scene the place 12 had been mowed down by 25-tonne lorry
An Italian girl is feared lacking within the Berlin Christmas market assault after her cell phone and journey go had been found within the aftermath of the atrocity that left 12 useless.
Fabrizia Lorenzo, 30, is a transport specialist working in Berlin however her cousin stated they'd not heard from her since final evening and revealed her private belongings had been discovered.
Not less than 12 had been killed and one other 48 injured when a 25-tonne hijacked truck ploughed by the busy festive market on Breitscheidplatz Sq., a busy procuring space in west Berlin.
Six of the useless are believed to be German and three are Hungarian. An Israeli man in his sixties is being handled for his accidents in hospital and his spouse remains to be lacking.
Berlin police right now admitted the Pakistani refugee they arrested in connection to the assault was the fallacious man and the actual attacker remains to be on the free and armed.
Lacking: Fabrizia Lorenzo, pictured, 30, is a transport specialist working in Berlin however her cousin stated they'd not heard from her since final evening
Concern: In a heartbreaking plea for assist, her cousin tweeted right now: 'My cousin (Fabrizia Di Lorenzo) not replying to us since yesterday evening'
Atrocity: Not less than 12 had been killed and one other 48 injured when a 25-tonne hijacked truck ploughed by the busy festive market on Breitscheidplatz Sq.
In a heartbreaking plea for assist, her cousin tweeted right now: 'My cousin (Fabrizia Di Lorenzo) not replying to us since yesterday evening. Somebody discovered her cellphone and metro go on the positioning.'
The names of the victims have but to be launched however authorities have recommended Ms Lorenzo, who hails from the Italian city of Sulmona in Abruzzia, could possibly be amongst them.
Police confirmed a cell phone discovered on the crime scene was registered to her.
In the meantime Italy's ambassador to Germany, Pietro Benassi, stated: 'I can affirm we're looking for somebody and we concern for her.'
The German overseas ministry is alleged to keep in touch along with her mom and brother who're already on their solution to the nation to submit DNA samples, Italian web site Repubblica reported.
Her father, who works at a publish workplace in Sulmona, is flying to Germany from Rome this night.
Ms Lorenzo's final tweet got here on December 5, when she shared a scene from award profitable movie, The Finest Of Youth.
Thriller: Police confirmed a cell phone discovered on the crime scene was registered to Ms Lorenzo, who graduated from the College of Bologna in 2012
Assault: The German overseas ministry is alleged to keep in touch with Ms Lorenzo's mom and brother who're already on their solution to the nation to submit DNA pattern, it has been reported. Pictured: Police and photographers encompass the truck used within the assault in Berlin
Destruction: Ms Lorenzo's final tweet got here on December 5, when she shared a scene from award profitable movie, The Finest Of Youth. Pictured: The lorry used to mow down dozens of individuals at a Christmas market in Berlin
Her many social media posts counsel she was each liberal and pro-refugee in a rustic which has been divided over the migrant disaster and the more moderen burqa ban.
In March she shared an interview with Polish sociologist Zygmunt Bauman who argued a spike in immigration isn't associated to a rise in terrorism.
One other piece shared along with her 246 followers pointed to analysis recommended the vast majority of Muslims dwelling in nations the place
Ms Lorenzo graduated from thee the College of Bologna with a level in Worldwide Relations and Diplomacy in 2012.
She started working in Germany in November 2013, in response to her LinkedIn profile, as a buyer companies coach for electronics firm Bosch.
Simply over a yr later she joined provide chain administration firm 4Flow, the place she labored as a transport specialist.
Among the many 48 injured is an aged Israeli man whose spouse has not been seen because the assault, the Overseas Ministry in Jerusalem stated.
He was significantly wounded and needed to endure surgical procedure however his life isn't believed to be at risk, the Occasions of Israel reported.
Assault: German police have stated the Pakistani refugee arrested and accused of being the motive force is the fallacious man
A senior police officer stated: 'We've got the fallacious man... The true perpetrator remains to be armed, at giant and may trigger additional injury'
A senior police chief has confirmed the Berlin Christmas market killer should be on the run, and able to inflict 'additional injury', 12 hours after Pakistani asylum seeker Naved B was arrested.
Detectives interrogating the 23-year-old suspect stated there was no blood on his garments, he suffered no accidents and denies hijacking the lorry which tore by a festive market at 40mph.
A senior police officer, instructed die Welt newspaper: 'We've got the fallacious man. So we've a brand new state of affairs. The true perpetrator remains to be armed, at giant and may trigger additional injury.'
Witnesses stated victims together with youngsters had been despatched flying like bowling pins and sucked below the wheels leaving 'rivers of blood' because the killer driver steered at them earlier than leaping out of the cab and racing from the scene.
Medics are furiously working to deal with these injured on the scene, after the truck brought about carnage and left sheer carnage behind it
Related Posts :
Bernie Sanders supporter refuses to help stranded motorist because she had a Trump bumper sticker
Teams compete in the annual Boxing Day barrel relay race in CambridgeshireThe Queen 'DID back leaving the EU'! Monarch told guests at a private lunch: 'I don't see why we can't just get out
Fitness model reveals the shocking toll her quest for the 'perfect body' took
'I found him dead in bed': George Michael's hairdresser lover tells how he discovered his boyfriend's lifeless body - as grief-stricken fans flock to the singer's home
0 Response to "Police hunting Berlin market killer are stumped after releasing their sole suspect"
Post a Comment